At any given time there are usually a few questions or thoughts that linger in my mind for days, weeks, months, and even years. They sit like minimized tabs, easily accessible if I have a spare moment. Sometimes they are resolved and filed away (here is a blog post about one such occasion). Sometimes they don’t have a simple answer.
One of those thoughts centers on that which is new versus that which is familiar. Do I like new things and experiences more than old things and experiences? I’m convinced that the answer is not limited to one side, rather it is a sliding meter (measured by a Preferosity Meter, of course).
It helps to think of real life situations.
Case Study 1: People
When I meet someone I know I have shared experiences, knowledge of interests, and background information from which to build a conversation. A first impression has already been made, so there is no pressure regarding that either. A new person brings all sorts of unknowns. This can be a very good thing. As an introvert I can only handle a limited amount of new people at a time.
Preferosity Meter says 80:20
Case Study 2: Places
In a familiar place I know the roads, locations of stores and restaurants, and how the weather behaves. A new place offers unseen sights, discovery, and adventure. I’m perfectly happy to stay in the familiar, though occasional trips to the new are fine.
Case Study 3: Beer
This is what prompted the original question. I noticed that I liked Spaten Optimator when it was new to me, yet quickly grew tired of it. On the other hand, I was initially disappointed with Dos Equis Lager Especial, but grew to appreciate it over time. I think I like the novelty in stronger, darker beers, yet prefer familiarity with the lighter ones.
Preferosity Meter says 50:50
Case Study 4: Music
When it comes to pure enjoyment level, I think familiar music has more potential than new music. I’ve never been able to fully appreciate a song when it was brand new to me. The fullest appreciation comes over time. That being said, at some point over-exposure can lead to despising a song (Top 40 radio stations are good at overplaying new songs). While I enjoy discovering new music, my real enjoyment comes from making that new music familiar music, so I’d have to say I lean to the left.
Preferosity Meter says 80:20
Case Study 5: Toilet Paper
I have a pretty strong preference for new toilet paper.
Preferosity Meter says 0:100
Conclusion
My preferences tend to lean toward the left. In many cases I can tolerate–or even enjoy–the right, but my contented nature does not demand it. I’d say I tend to rate around 71:29 on the Preferosity Meter.
Where do you fall on the Preferosity Meter?